Online library joining: all 16 named policy records
Original factual policy comparison by Alisson Bento. Sources: the named official library systems and their linked policy pages, with exact URLs and timestamps retained below. No affiliation or endorsement. Original-work reuse terms do not license the underlying policy pages.
Dated factual policy comparison, observed 28 October 2026. Sixteen predeclared named systems across six continents form a purposive, unweighted panel; not a world census or quality ranking. Eleven usable source records and five unresolved intake cases remain visible. Seven broad remote digital routes include four named ebook/audiobook access routes, of which two explicitly establish borrowing or loan eligibility: 2 is a subset of 4, which is a subset of 7. Fourteen strict loan routes are not established, not absent. Selected-route renewal is not established for all 16 because systematic coding was deferred. Source failures are provenance, not policies. No application, verification, payment or checkout was tested; consult the current official system page.
Technical export in English. Use horizontal scrolling to inspect every column. Categorical unknowns and failed-intake provenance remain explicit; empty publication-date fields do not mean an undated policy is invalid.
| id | city | system | region | policy_path_state | eligibility_geography | verification_route | digital_collection_scope | digital_borrowing_scope | remote_named_material_access | remote_ebook_audiobook_route | evidence_endpoint_relation | strict_material_evidence_note | initial_validity_or_expiry | renewal_in_person | renewal_coding_status | fee_for_selected_route | policy_publication_or_update_date | interpretation_note | source_urls | source_sha256 | source_observation_utc | attempted_source_provenance | actual_registration_tested |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LAPL | Los Angeles | Los Angeles Public Library (city, not county) | North America | remote_digital_route_explicit | Los Angeles City residents for the e-card; full resident cards have broader California eligibility. | Instant online e-card stated; detailed identity-verification mechanism not stated on the inspected policy page. | E-card is linked to the library digital offer; physical preregistration separately requires a library visit. | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Instant e-card/digital vendors explicitly connected; named ebook/audiobook borrowing eligibility is not explicit in the inspected e-card body. Site-navigation ebook labels and a generic checkout table are insufficient. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Not separately stated for the e-card on this page. | City is not county. Non-California cards are explicitly issued/renewed in person for a stated fee; that is a different route. | ["https://www.lapl.org/library-card/borrowing-policies-and-information"] | ["71f0d5da26d9028530fdf4570c6d9c0bd796c6eaa3dfe3ff0fb89e6e29ac2630"] | ["2026-10-28T23:51:58.892848+00:00"] | [] | False | |
| NYPL | New York | New York Public Library (not Queens or Brooklyn systems) | North America | not_established | Not coded from denied page. | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Usable primary evidence for this criterion was not established; this is not a negative policy finding. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | not_established | Primary NYPL page returned 403 through web; no retry or alternate route. Missing evidence is not a negative policy finding. | [] | [] | [] | [{"url": "https://www.nypl.org/library-card/new", "http_status": 403, "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-28T23:52:21.434993+00:00", "policy_evidence": false}] | False | |
| TPL | Toronto | Toronto Public Library | North America | not_established | Not coded from denied frozen intake. | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Usable primary evidence for this criterion was not established; this is not a negative policy finding. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | not_established | First direct primary-policy request returned 403; shared host hold retained. Search-render discovery was not substituted for frozen policy review. | [] | [] | [] | [{"url": "https://tpl.ca/help/your-library-card/digital-access-card/", "http_status": 403, "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-28T23:51:59.527706+00:00", "policy_evidence": false}] | False | |
| BIBLION | São Paulo | BibliON, State of São Paulo digital library (state system) | South America | remote_digital_route_explicit | Residents of Brazil, according to the current FAQ; this is a São Paulo state initiative rather than only a city service. | Web/app signup, published CPF or RNM and address fields, then an email activation link. No registration was performed. | Digital books and audiobooks described. | explicit_ebook_or_audiobook_borrowing | explicit_remote_route_and_named_ebook_audiobook_access | explicit_remote_route_and_material_eligibility | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Named ebook/audiobook borrowing is documented; this alone does not establish remote initial issue. | Not stated for membership; the 15-day loan term is a different clock. | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Free, explicitly stated. | Do not use the project name São Paulo to infer that only São Paulo residents qualify. No identity document or personal data entered. | ["https://www.biblion.org.br/index.php"] | ["c2a8d91dd431e4755db1e566f72857612a14a28f942ff205f6ed67345caaf15c"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:22.007863+00:00"] | [] | False | |
| BIBLORED | Bogotá | BibloRed / Biblioteca Digital de Bogotá | South America | remote_digital_route_explicit | The published guide explicitly permits digital use by affiliated people outside Bogotá or outside Colombia. | Online form followed by a staff telephone call to finish affiliation, then a downloadable digital card. | Biblioteca Digital de Bogotá; physical loans remain restricted for affiliates outside the city/country. | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Remote affiliation and digital-library content are explicit; this frozen guide does not explicitly establish ebook/audiobook borrowing eligibility. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Free affiliation stated. | 2026-05-06 | Online is not synonymous with automated or instant. Exact timing and successful application were not tested. | ["https://biblored.gov.co/noticias/afiliaciones-biblored-instructivo-beneficios-usuarios"] | ["4fbeb582774c02d63bd3513884ce093b70d8d7a513f0c4cea9d321318204232e"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:00.417833+00:00"] | [] | False |
| VOEBB | Berlin | Verbund der Öffentlichen Bibliotheken Berlins | Europe | remote_digital_route_explicit | Address fields and a fixed postcode list are displayed; the complete residence-eligibility universe is not established by this page. | Online registration advertised with payment by SEPA, credit card or PayPal; page says direct digital use. | Digital offer including magazines and newspapers; no platform or file compatibility was tested. | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Direct digital offer explicitly names magazines/newspapers; this frozen online-registration page does not explicitly establish ebook/audiobook borrowing eligibility. | Annual contribution stated, but exact expiry/renewal rule is not stated. | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | EUR 10 annual online contribution; concessions are explicitly unavailable online. | Applicants seeking a discounted tariff are directed to a library. Age 16+ online is published; this adult-only panel does not evaluate child routes. | ["https://www.voebb.de/aDISWeb/app/prod00?sp=SBN00000000&sp=SDE"] | ["05366023feed2abf835f4263cec4dd1b9e9f86df3a74dab450249c3762a69cf1"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:02.013585+00:00"] | [] | False | |
| WESTMINSTER | London | Westminster Libraries (borough, not all London) | Europe | remote_digital_route_explicit | Adults with a permanent Westminster address, proof of ID and a smartphone; digital card starts at 16. | MyWestminster digital card, smartphone wallet and immediate online library services described. | Official companion page links online membership to ebooks and eaudiobooks. | not_established | explicit_remote_route_and_named_ebook_audiobook_access | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | The companion page explicitly grants immediate ebook/eaudiobook access; a loan/borrowing transaction is not explicit in the frozen body. Named-material access is supported separately. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Free for eligible digital-card applicants. | 2026-10-14 | The broader physical-card route permits international addresses; that does not make its digital card available to all visitors. | ["https://www.westminster.gov.uk/leisure-libraries-and-community/libraries/how-join-library", "https://www.westminster.gov.uk/leisure-libraries-and-community/libraries/latest-updates/online-resources"] | ["cb3e12bfca7749cacbf4cba2e1322607ab60b4755820daf265c5d251595be9a8", "ee2e075d07e3a5e2ef8e42a951ac052d8632f6cf663690757885253c64a9ba71"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:01.087689+00:00", "2026-10-28T23:52:01.480797+00:00"] | [] | False |
| PARIS | Paris | Bibliothèques municipales de Paris | Europe | branch_step_in_described_route | Ordinary lending-library registration is open to Parisians and non-Parisians; specialized library cards alone generally do not qualify for the digital library. | The inspected registration route describes registration desks in libraries with identity documents. | Digital loans require an up-to-date, unblocked lending-library card; source minimum age 15. | explicit_ebook_or_audiobook_borrowing | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Named ebook/audiobook borrowing is documented; this alone does not establish remote initial issue. | Ordinary card valid one year; this is not an ebook loan expiry. | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Digital access free for qualifying current lending-library cardholders. | 2026-06-09 | A branch step is documented for the described route. No claim that every possible remote exception is impossible; separate digital-only remote issue was not established. | ["https://www.paris.fr/pages/bibliotheques-infos-pratiques-2507/", "https://bibliotheques.paris.fr/numerique/conditions-dacces-et-de-pret.aspx"] | ["88b2acbf941277b4c10a65548f2b5316b19c790db85646a113e8cd2e362688db", "28af661f6fcf680ff956a278dc0c234f7fc5d7e54329baf1d18014e9eaa63e90"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:03.238267+00:00", "2026-10-28T23:58:38.607271+00:00"] | [] | False |
| MADRID | Madrid | Bibliotecas de la Comunidad de Madrid (regional system) | Europe | not_established | Primary card and procedure pages were discovered, but frozen requests returned 504. | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Usable primary evidence for this criterion was not established; this is not a negative policy finding. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | not_established | No success or negative policy inferred from gateway errors; no retries or alternate paths. | [] | [] | [] | [{"url": "https://www.comunidad.madrid/portal-lector/solicita-tu-carne", "http_status": 504, "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-28T23:52:32.293016+00:00", "policy_evidence": false}, {"url": "https://sede.comunidad.madrid/autorizaciones-licencias-permisos-carnes/carne-lector-bibliotecas?page=%2C1", "http_status": 504, "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-28T23:52:33.495165+00:00", "policy_evidence": false}] | False | |
| NLB | Singapore | National Library Board public libraries (national system) | Asia | not_established | The primary membership route returned 202 with an empty body in direct intake. | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Usable primary evidence for this criterion was not established; this is not a negative policy finding. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | not_established | No citizenship, foreigner fee, Singpass or renewal result is coded from old guides or empty current responses. | [] | [] | [] | [{"url": "https://www.nlb.gov.sg/main/services/library-membership", "http_status": 202, "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-28T23:52:22.293246+00:00", "policy_evidence": false}] | False | |
| HKPL | Hong Kong | Hong Kong Public Libraries | Asia | remote_digital_route_explicit | Eligible Hong Kong SAR residents applying for their first card or E-Account. | Type A E-Account: adult online form and Hong Kong Identity Card copy; policy explicitly says no in-person completion required. | Ebooks and other e-resources; Type A does not permit physical borrowing. | explicit_ebook_or_audiobook_borrowing | explicit_remote_route_and_named_ebook_audiobook_access | explicit_remote_route_and_material_eligibility | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Named ebook/audiobook borrowing is documented; this alone does not establish remote initial issue. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Not stated on the inspected page. | Type B physical-card path includes a branch visit; Type C has an iAMSmart+ route. These alternatives must not be collapsed into one mandatory branch step. | ["https://www.hkpl.gov.hk/en/about-us/services/borrower-reg/notes.html"] | ["5540561773aca33426312a6ee7cdad71e74a1637ff27dd48148fb0e7083d16b4"] | ["2026-10-28T23:54:17.009849+00:00"] | [] | False | |
| SEOUL | Seoul | Seoul Metropolitan Library | Asia | remote_digital_route_explicit | Registered Seoul residents; separate qualified employees/students in Seoul and stated overseas-Korean categories. | Resident route uses government non-face-to-face qualification confirmation. Work/school routes require document review. | Online-issued mobile cards permit ebooks, audiobooks and electronic magazines; some nonresident categories cannot borrow physical books. | not_established | explicit_remote_route_and_named_ebook_audiobook_access | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | The membership page explicitly permits ebook/audiobook services; a loan/borrowing transaction is not explicit in the frozen body. Named-material access is supported separately. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Initial-issue fee not stated; listed replacement-card fees are not initial membership fees. | Resident issuance and reviewed work/school applications have different timing and privileges; physical plastic cards require an in-person visit. | ["https://lib.seoul.go.kr/rwww/html/en/membership.jsp"] | ["c5328892221ff79aadf3de87c4ddb9df7a5e4182df00408442f1bd599d190af3"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:41.993678+00:00"] | [] | False | |
| CAPETOWN | Cape Town | City of Cape Town Libraries | Africa | branch_step_in_described_route | Cape Town residents have free cards; nonresident and temporary memberships are separately described. | Published process asks applicants to hand a form, ID and address evidence to their nearest library. | City department confirms ebooks/eaudiobooks through its digital collection; a remote-only issue route was not established. | explicit_ebook_or_audiobook_borrowing | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | The department explicitly advertises borrowing ebooks/eaudiobooks through Libby. The inspected membership route includes a branch step; remote initial issue remains not established. | Different nonresident/temporary terms are published; remote-digital validity not established. | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Resident card free; other card types have distinct fees. | Documented branch route is not a conclusive absence of all remote exceptions. The linked tariff sheet was not inspected; nonresident/temporary fee amounts are not established. | ["https://www.capetown.gov.za/city-connect/register/information-and-learning/register-for-a-city-library-membership/", "https://www.capetown.gov.za/departments/library-and-information-services-department/"] | ["a49738224b8be6f6ded1caebfe7db95c6c5337bf460dcf658b6beefda956aa6e", "acb917d0bc16e481764f2236b71933ece862f4458b93f887b34fbf9117129e19"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:32.956814+00:00", "2026-10-28T23:52:33.308795+00:00"] | [] | False | |
| SYDNEY | Sydney | City of Sydney Library | Oceania | branch_step_in_described_route | Full card: NSW residential address. Visitor and temporary membership are separate routes. | Main join page says apply online, then visit a branch to confirm identity. | Membership description includes online collections from home; separate digital-only instant access was not established. | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Home online collections are advertised, but the inspected membership page does not explicitly name ebook/audiobook borrowing eligibility. | Published standard types: 3 years full, 3 months visitor, 12 months temporary; no distinct remote-only validity established. | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Membership free, explicitly stated. | Do not label a digital card inside an app as proof of remote initial issuance. Home-library exceptions exist and need their own scope. | ["https://www.cityofsydney.nsw.gov.au/library-information-services/join-the-library"] | ["ad18dd6cc5e623a381150dd22f746ff2d631f494cd20bb6580df2d0fdd86c703"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:35.221883+00:00"] | [] | False | |
| AUCKLAND | Auckland | Auckland Libraries | Oceania | not_established | Direct primary join-page request returned 406. | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Usable primary evidence for this criterion was not established; this is not a negative policy finding. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | not_established | The discovery form alone was not used to infer end-to-end ebook eligibility; no request repeated. | [] | [] | [] | [{"url": "https://www.aucklandlibraries.govt.nz/en/join-the-library.html", "http_status": 406, "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-28T23:52:33.887203+00:00", "policy_evidence": false}] | False | |
| SLV | Melbourne | State Library Victoria (state system) | Oceania | digital_access_advertised_verification_unresolved | Victorian residents for the free Access digital card. | The current membership page advertises a digital card and links online joining; detailed verification and any branch step are not established. | Ebooks, ejournals, magazines and newspapers; reference access is not automatically equivalent to public-library ebook borrowing. | not_established | not_established | not_established | Nested positive evidence: borrowing subset of named-material access subset of broad digital access; counts are not additive. Not established is not absent. | Ebook access is advertised, but the inspected page does not establish a borrowing collection or end-to-end branch-free verification. | not_established | not_established | deferred_not_systematically_coded_for_selected_digital_route | Free Access tier; paid supporter/student/family tiers are separate. | Retained as partial evidence rather than counted as an explicitly branch-free issuance route. Do not confuse paid tiers with the free reading-access tier. | ["https://www.slv.vic.gov.au/node/4826165"] | ["3a86750e8d9eb44e575f1e7df1a1184aab76cc04305a459a62de3a7521596a6f"] | ["2026-10-28T23:52:35.411811+00:00"] | [] | False |