Skip to content

Book Reviews

Monarch by Sophie Lark: Gothic-Protector Fit

Elena's mail-order-bride gamble, a castle with hidden chambers and Atlas as ally: premise, what fans praise, content notes and Grimstone reading order.

6 min readUpdated
Share article

Sheer white curtains drift beside tall windows in a moonlit Victorian hallway, with a single candle on a side table.

Monarch is for readers who want a romantic escape plan to curdle into gothic danger, with a possible ally standing outside the intended relationship. The fiancé and the protector in this story are two different men, and the difference matters if you tend to choose dark romances by possessive-hero shorthand.

A bookstore worker, a castle and a way out of town

The publisher’s listing introduces Elena Zelenska, a twenty-seven-year-old bookstore worker who becomes a mail-order bride to escape her hometown. She falls quickly for Benjamin Wittacker, a handsome single father and published author who seems almost too good to be true, and who begins building her a castle in the woods. Once she reaches Grimstone, the fairytale turns sinister. The castle is a maze of hidden rooms, Ben looks less like a prince than a threat, and his jealousy and control grow.

Elena’s main source of support is Atlas Covett, who runs the Monarch hotel. The description calls him stern and imposing, so much so that even his staff are afraid of him, and says his hotel becomes a refuge from her fiancé’s controlling behavior. The marketing is explicit about the frame: this is a romantic thriller about getting out before the castle becomes a prison. The same listing gives the imprint as Bloom Books, the format as a 300-page paperback and the publication date as October 8, 2024; page counts and dates can vary by edition.

Two men, two kinds of power

The question for readers arriving from the first Grimstone book is whether the suspense-and-romance balance will feel familiar. The setup differs in a useful way. In Grimstone, as described on the Penguin NZ listing for the first book, Remi Hayes inherits a moldering mansion, Blackleaf Manor, and is blackmailed by Dane Covett, the doctor next door, whom everyone in town reportedly thinks murdered his wife; she must decide whether he is the one haunting her nights or is trying to protect her from something worse. That ambiguity sits inside a single man. Monarch splits it. The blurb sets a fiancé who “might just be a monster” against a hotel owner who offers solace and sanctuary, so the romantic and the threatening roles are, at least on the surface, assigned to different people.

That is worth thinking about before you start. If you enjoyed the push and pull of not knowing whether a hero is safe, a premise that names its menace early may feel more straightforward. If you disliked that uncertainty, the clearer line between danger and refuge may be the point. Either way, the description frames Atlas as an ally first and a love interest by implication; the listing calls him her only ally while she is isolated far from home. Whether the book treats that alliance as a romance that grows from trust, or as another form of power over a woman with few options, is the thing to watch as you read.

The two Covett surnames link the books on the surface, but the listings do not say whether Atlas and Dane are related, so any family link is unconfirmed.

The building is part of the threat

Gothic romance depends on place, and here the place is a gift that turns into a trap. A castle built for a bride, hidden chambers and a woods setting far from home all point to isolation as the main source of danger. That is a different engine from a menacing person in a crowded city. It rewards readers who like atmosphere and slow realization, where a detail that first reads as romantic reveals itself as a mechanism of control.

The listing calls Grimstone a gothic, secretive beach town, which suggests rumor and small-town watchfulness as well as private menace, though the description does not spell that out. It does not say whose point of view carries the chapters, whether the story is told in first or third person, or how the thriller plot resolves, so those are open questions as you start.

Series position and the author

Goodreads’ Grimstone series page lists two books, Grimstone (2023) and Monarch (2024), both by Sophie Lark, in that order. Our Grimstone review covers the first. The blurb describes Lark as a USA Today bestselling author, and Monarch is presented as a romantic thriller rather than a straight dark romance, so it may suit readers who want a mystery line alongside the relationship.

What readers praise about Monarch

Readers on major book-review sites most often single out Atlas Covett, describing him as protective, gentle and swoon-worthy beneath a gruff exterior and calling him the standout of the book. Several praise the slow-burn chemistry between Elena and Atlas as emotionally satisfying, and readers who enjoy romantic thrillers say the mystery and twists kept them hooked, so the book reads as a romantic thriller that balances suspense with a slow-burn love story.

Many fans love the gothic, spooky, autumn atmosphere of the eerie town of Grimstone and call the book a good fall or Halloween read. Others praise the quick, easy-to-read pacing, the illustrations that appear inside the chapters and the dual-narrator audiobook, which some listeners found well done. A silent young girl who appears in the story is also often called a highlight.

The Vampire King’s Obsession — book cover

From Alisson Bento’s books

The Vampire King’s Obsession

Vampire

A vampire romance about a hero who claims her and never lets anyone forget it.

Buy on Amazon

Kindle edition · Check Kindle Unlimited availability on Amazon.

Content notes

No author-published content-note list turned up for this book. The description itself mentions a fiancé whose jealousy and control escalate, a heroine who is isolated far from home and a castle with hidden chambers. That is not a comprehensive inventory. Anyone with limits around coercive control, confinement, violence or explicit content should consult the current edition’s notes before reading.

Who will like it, who may skip it

The likely audience is readers who like a bookish heroine reassessing a choice that seemed hopeful, a gothic setting that does real work and a protector figure who is more intimidating than comforting. It may be a poor fit if you want a romance without a controlling partner as the central menace, if you prefer a heroine who is not isolated, or if you want a book whose danger is mostly supernatural. In the first chapters, look for:

  • The first warning signs: how early Ben’s charm gives way to something else, and whether Elena notices.
  • Elena’s agency: whether she makes her own plans or mostly reacts.
  • Atlas’s first scenes: whether his intimidating manner reads as protective or as another form of control.
  • The castle: how the hidden chambers are introduced and whether the geography is clear.

Reading alongside

Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca is described by Britannica as a 1938 suspense novel set in Cornwall at a great house called Manderley, with a shy young woman who marries an older widower and feels overshadowed by his first wife. The shared ground is the new bride in an imposing house whose master is not what he appears. Monarch is a modern romantic thriller whose description advertises an outside protector; Rebecca is a classic of suspense with a very different historical setting. These are premise-level comparisons, not promises about tone or heat.

A locked room and a gentler free story from Alisson Bento

His Dark Eden by Alisson Bento introduces injured Viola waking after a yacht explosion in a luxurious room with sealed windows and a locked door. It connects through safety becoming uncertain inside an appealing space, but differs through immediate confinement after apparent rescue, rather than Elena’s mail-order engagement and an outside hotel-owner ally. Browse the dark romance shelf to compare. The free story The House Below the Signal pairs conservator Nora Bell and an electrician around records during storm isolation. It is an original adult M/F story that precedes The Blizzard Between Us, with consensual kisses and non-graphic intimacy. Read online; email access unlocks later chapters.

Sources checked 20–21 October 2026. Reading suggestions compare advertised premises; they promise no matching heat, consent dynamics or endings.

Share

This guide is published by Alisson Bento. It may discuss and link to books by Alisson Bento and other authors. About the author and this site

From curiosity to chapter one

Your next can’t-put-it-down.

Explore the books

Read on Kindle or borrow with Kindle Unlimited where available. Check your local Amazon store for current eligibility.

Pass it on.

Monarch by Sophie Lark: Gothic-Protector Fitalissonbento.com

WhatsAppFacebookXTelegramRedditThreadsEmailSMS