Skip to content

Public book supply · Historical Odisha audit records

Which Textbook Supply Gap Can the Record Actually Locate? Odisha, 2018–23

Required, printed, supplied and available books answer different questions. A structured historical reference shows how to investigate each count without mistaking a balanced total for a complete textbook set.

Published
Share
Share this page
EmailCite & reuse this study
Key findings as text
Reusable imagesWhich Textbook Supply Gap Can the Record Actually Locate? Odisha, 2018–23 — 89.74 + 4.72: Annual book-count differences, in lakh. Required minus printed, plus printed minus supplied; five academic years. Rounded source quantities, not causal attribution.Download sharing image (JPG) ↓

Key findings

89.74 + 4.72

Annual book-count differences, in lakh

Required minus printed, plus printed minus supplied; five academic years. Rounded source quantities, not causal attribution.

58,690 + 35,495

Separate sampled-block count terms

Local quantity deficits plus remaining school-supply gaps; nine audit-window records including prior-year stock, not statewide annual cohorts.

0 ≠ all needs met

Semiliguda is an essential scope warning

A balanced appendix row coexists with a separate account of unmet requests covering 32,827 textbooks for 2018–22. The scopes are not silently reconciled.

Read the book supply chain through separate records

A school can be waiting for the right textbook even when a warehouse total looks reassuring. The practical question is therefore more specific than whether enough books were printed. Which quantities were requested, recorded as printed, supplied to local collection points, and sent onward to schools? Which titles and classes do those quantities describe? This reference makes those questions easier to ask using a historical public audit of school education in Odisha, India. It offers a structured account of reported book counts rather than an assessment of any child’s reading ability.

The source is the Comptroller and Auditor General of India’s Report No. 5 of 2025 on School Education in the State, Government of Odisha. Its records concern 2018–19 through 2022–23. Our contribution is a reproducible secondary reference: two small aggregate datasets, explicit calculations and separate views of statewide annual supply and sampled block inventories. The audit already identified shortages, late supply, subject imbalances and incomplete textbook sets. Those findings belong to CAG; organizing their underlying counts does not make them newly discovered problems.

Keep the historical dates visible

CAG conducted the performance audit between April and December 2023. The report was sent to the state government on 8 October 2025 and tabled on 9 December 2025. These dates describe different events. A report released in 2025 can examine books ordered several years earlier. A secondary reference prepared after publication does not update those deliveries. Nothing in this analysis establishes the availability of books in an Odisha school in 2026 or the quality of a current procurement programme.

This distinction changes how a parent, school committee or journalist should use the evidence. The figures can support a question about how the supply process was documented and what a new monitoring record ought to contain. They cannot tell a family whether today’s book has reached its school. For that decision, the relevant evidence would be the current class, subject, edition, language, order and receipt record. A historical total is useful background, but it should not replace a dated answer about the book a pupil actually needs.

Five annual cohorts measure book quantities

The first dataset transcribes Table 8.3, which gives required, printed and supplied textbook quantities for five academic years. The unit is lakh books: one lakh equals 100,000 books. It is not a currency unit. The source reports these quantities to two decimal places in lakh, corresponding to displayed increments of 1,000 books. Calculations preserve that precision. A difference obtained from two rounded figures is arithmetic on the displayed values, not independent evidence of an exact count of individually traced books.

For each year, we subtract printed books from required books and supplied books from printed books. Adding those two differences reproduces the reported required-minus-supplied difference. This gives an intelligible way to read the table without assigning a cause to either remainder. A recorded printing difference is not automatically a printer’s fault, and a difference between printed and supplied totals does not establish that matching, usable books were ready for immediate dispatch. The published aggregate records do not follow individual copies through those events.

The annual balance is a useful first question

Across the five reported years, required-minus-printed totals 89.74 lakh books, while printed-minus-supplied totals 4.72 lakh. Their sum is 94.46 lakh, the required-minus-supplied quantity already reported by CAG. These are three connected descriptions of the same annual table, not three additional shortages. A procurement discussion that starts only at transport would leave the much larger recorded requirement-to-printing difference unexamined. Conversely, the smaller printing-to-supply difference should remain visible rather than disappear inside the combined total.

These balances help an oversight meeting choose the next document to request. The first difference calls for the title-level requirement, final print authorization, revised orders and completed quantities. The second calls for reconciliation of completed print records and supply receipts. Those are suggested verification routes, not explanations proved by the audit table. A cancelled edition, a revised requirement, an accounting cut-off or an actual delivery failure would need its own evidence. The reference identifies a question that a record holder can answer; it does not decide the answer in advance.

An equal printed and supplied total does not close the story

The 2020–21 row makes the distinction especially clear. Both printed and supplied quantities are 253.89 lakh, so their displayed difference is 0.00 lakh. The same row records a requirement of 296.72 lakh, leaving 42.83 lakh between requirement and supply. It would be misleading to describe that year simply as complete delivery because the two middle figures agree. Agreement at one comparison does not resolve a different comparison, and it does not establish that all pupils received appropriate books before lessons began.

This is a historical year overlapping the COVID-19 period, but the table alone does not estimate a pandemic effect. We do not compare it with an invented normal delivery calendar or assign all differences to school closures. The useful lesson is a reporting design choice: keep the original requirement visible beside completion totals, identify any revision separately, and preserve the unit and reporting period. Otherwise a reassuring completion ratio can answer a narrower administrative question than the one a school or family intended to ask.

Deadline endpoints answer a different question

Table 8.2 supplies a due date and the last date of supply at block points for each corresponding academic year. We reproduce the calendar differences against the table’s 15 March due dates: 90, 130, 191, 198 and 195 days. These are endpoint delays. They are not average delays, the length of time every book was late, or the number of days every pupil waited. We retain them in a separate table so they cannot quietly become a timing weight attached to all the annual book quantities.

The distinction matters for a reader deciding how much a late final delivery tells them. A last supply date can establish that the recorded supply process extended beyond its stated deadline. It cannot reveal what proportion arrived before the deadline, whether one small title or a large part of the order was involved, or when schools distributed complete sets. Those questions require dated quantities for individual consignments and receipts. Multiplying an annual shortfall by an endpoint delay would create a book-days statistic that these records do not support.

The sampled block records are a separate view

The second dataset comes from Appendix 8.4. It contains nine sampled block records, with required books, books available including previous-year stock, books supplied to schools, books not supplied against requirement and books kept idle at block points. The chapter discusses these records within the 2018–23 audit window. They are not a new-stock panel containing one observation for every block in each year, and the appendix does not provide a single common inventory date that would justify calling it a 2023 stock snapshot.

The statewide annual rows and these local records must therefore remain separate. The block quantities are not a denominator for the statewide printing figures. Their available stock includes earlier stock, while the annual table reports printing and supply for academic-year cohorts. We do not draw a combined funnel from the state order to these nine blocks, estimate what share of the statewide shortage they explain, or scale their patterns to all of Odisha. Their value is a closer view of what different local count configurations can mean for a follow-up enquiry.

Read the local quantity envelope carefully

For a block, let requirement be the reported number needed, availability the reported number on hand including previous-year stock, and supply the number sent to schools. We calculate a local quantity deficit as the positive part of requirement minus availability. We then calculate the remaining school-supply gap as the smaller of requirement and availability, minus supply. The two terms add to requirement minus supply. This decomposition separates an aggregate count insufficiency from the rest of the reported school-supply gap without pretending to identify an operational cause.

The word remaining is important. That second term is not a count of usable books withheld from pupils, matching books available for transfer or complete sets that could immediately have been issued. The source itself says some subjects were supplied below requirement and others above it. An extra mathematics book cannot be assumed to replace a missing language book; an earlier edition may not satisfy a new order. The arithmetic envelope describes quantities before those essential matching tests. It gives a planner a reason to inspect the mix, not permission to treat every copy as interchangeable.

Different blocks suggest different records to inspect

Nandahandi illustrates a straightforward aggregate count insufficiency. Its appendix row reports 290,046 required books, 255,809 available and the same 255,809 supplied to schools. The local quantity deficit is 34,237 and the remaining school-supply gap is zero. Within this row, all recorded available books were sent onward, but their number remained below requirement. That does not prove which titles were missing or when they were needed. It does make an enquiry limited to unissued local inventory an incomplete response to the recorded quantity gap.

Bhandaripokhari presents a different configuration: 370,718 required, 372,403 available and 359,768 supplied. Boipariguda records requirement and availability of 423,012, with 418,100 supplied. Their remaining school-supply gaps are 10,950 and 4,912 respectively. The rows show enough aggregate available copies to equal the stated requirements, alongside lower school supply. A useful follow-up would reconcile subject, class, edition, language, condition, year and school requests. The figures do not establish that every needed book was present or that staff deliberately failed to issue usable stock.

Some records contain both kinds of count gap

Bonth and Ullunda each combine availability below requirement with supply below that availability. For Bonth, the two arithmetic terms are 2,944 and 10,445 books. For Ullunda, they are 21,509 and 9,188. Summed across all nine records, local quantity deficits total 58,690 books and remaining school-supply gaps total 35,495. Together they reproduce the appendix’s 94,185 books not supplied against requirement. These are exact arithmetic results from the reported integer block counts, unlike the rounded lakh quantities in the statewide annual table.

This is useful because the same unresolved school total can hide different record questions. In a block with both terms, checking only the additional quantity needed may overlook a separate issue in the available-stock and school-supply reconciliation. Checking only stock retained may overlook an overall insufficiency. The analysis still cannot prescribe the correct mix of printing, transfer or distribution. It can help a committee keep both enquiries open and ask that each answer be supported by a dated, title-specific record instead of a single aggregate assurance.

Idle stock is evidence to reconcile

The nine rows report 68,116 idle books in total. That number should not be subtracted from the 94,185 unmet school-supply quantity as though the answer were a ready-made redistribution plan. Some available stock exceeds the aggregate requirement in its block; other retained stock sits within the numerical requirement envelope. Neither observation confirms that it matches outstanding requests. The appendix’s inclusion of previous-year stock makes edition and year especially relevant. Transporting an inappropriate title would change a warehouse count without necessarily supplying the book a class needs.

A practical stock review would begin with identifiers and condition, not a target to empty the store. Record the title or publication code, class, medium, edition, usable quantity, actual requests and intended school. Compare that list with the shortages at the same level of detail. Only then can a responsible official determine whether a transfer is feasible or another print requirement is justified. This is a proposed monitoring method prompted by the audit’s reported mix problem, not a claim that such a matching exercise was performed in this study.

Semiliguda prevents a false all-clear

Semiliguda’s Appendix 8.4 row balances: requirement, availability and school supply each equal 369,281 books. Both of our count gaps are therefore zero. Yet the main text separately describes requests for 32,827 textbooks for academic sessions 2018–22 that were not supplied, despite requests made between May 2018 and June 2021. We retain this important warning beside the block results. We do not join the two statements into a single corrected figure, assume they share an identical scope, or decide which particular titles reconcile them.

A zero aggregate gap means only that the displayed counts balance within the appendix row. It is not proof that every request, title or school need was met. For a school committee, this is a concrete reason to preserve a request register even when the summary report appears complete. The register should allow an unresolved title to remain visible until a matching receipt closes it. An overall balanced total should trigger a check of outstanding requests, rather than automatically mark every individual request as fulfilled.

Full sets need their own evidence

The audit also reports student outcomes in Appendix 8.5: eligible students receiving full sets, partial sets or no books in 46 sampled schools across ten blocks. That is a different measurement from Appendix 8.4’s nine block inventories and its quantities for school supply. The student table helps explain why book totals matter, but we do not divide one table by the other to estimate books per child, children affected by a particular count remainder, or how many additional complete sets could have been assembled.

A complete set depends on its constituent titles, class and language. Counting copies is necessary for supply management but insufficient for confirming that the set is complete. A school-level record could identify each expected title and the number of eligible pupils, then show matching receipts and issue dates. This would allow a full-set indicator to be calculated from its actual components. The present reference makes no such calculation because the required cross-linked title and pupil data are not published in these two aggregate datasets.

A useful public update names its checkpoint

A statement that textbooks have been supplied should name the checkpoint it describes. It may mean printing completed, delivery to a block collection point, receipt by a school or issue to pupils. Those events can occur on different dates. A clear update would give the academic year, class, title group, quantity, receiving level and date, along with any unresolved balance. This suggested format makes an update more useful to the person waiting for a book without requiring publication of a pupil’s name or another personal identifier.

Families also benefit when partial delivery is described plainly. A school can distinguish titles already received from titles still expected and identify the person or office responsible for the next status update. It should not use an aggregate completion percentage as a promise about an unconfirmed title. These are communication recommendations based on the measurement limits exposed here. We have not contacted schools, tested a distribution portal, submitted requests or observed a current family’s experience, and we do not claim that a particular administrative workflow now operates.

Use the reference to prepare the next book order

For a publisher or public purchasing team, the annual and local views suggest complementary checks. Before printing, retain the approved title-level requirement and separately record revisions. After printing, reconcile completed quantities with dated supply receipts. At collection points, preserve opening stock, incoming books, school requests and outward supply with the same identifiers. At schools, retain receipt and issue records. These suggestions do not require a single universal software system; they require the descriptions to remain consistent enough for quantities to be matched across the chosen checkpoints.

The historical counts do not establish a cost saving from adopting these checks. No printing costs, transport routes, staff capacity or validated transfer plan enter this calculation. Nor can the figures identify who was responsible for a specific discrepancy. The immediate benefit is a better question: which book, for which class and year, at which checkpoint, with what remaining evidence? That question helps prevent an aggregate delivery declaration from closing a case whose title-level request remains unresolved. The answer must still come from the responsible current record holder.

Reproduce the numbers and preserve the limits

The downloadable factual CSV files use new column names and a simple structure, with CAG table and appendix attribution. The calculation script runs offline and uses decimal arithmetic for lakh values and integers for block counts. A separate recipe explains how a reader can obtain the official report independently, verify its file fingerprint and check the cited pages. The downloads do not include the report PDF, copied page layouts, photographs, logos or personal records. The source remains directly linked so the evidence can be examined in its full original context.

The safest use of this reference is as a historical, transparent book-supply checklist. Keep annual state cohorts separate from sampled local records, treat last supply as an endpoint, and ask for title-level matching before proposing action on retained stock. A zero count gap cannot certify fulfilled needs, as the Semiliguda example shows. These limits do not make the figures unhelpful. They identify exactly what a reported total can establish and what further evidence a reader, school or public purchasing team needs before treating it as an answer about actual textbook availability.

Annual gaps in recorded textbook quantities

Five statewide academic-year book cohorts, 2018–19 to 2022–23. The two count differences reproduce required minus supplied; they do not identify causes. Unit: lakh books at reported precision.

Full chart and source
Five annual bars split required-minus-printed and printed-minus-supplied quantities in lakh books. The 2020–21 printed-to-supplied difference is zero at reported precision, while required-minus-printed remains 42.83 lakh. No causal attribution.

Scroll horizontally to inspect the chart. ↔

Chart and values

Scroll horizontally to see all columns.

Five statewide annual book-count balances
Academic yearRequiredPrintedSuppliedRequired − printedPrinted − supplied
2018-19272.20260.09258.5612.111.53
2019-20261.25253.66252.057.591.61
2020-21296.72253.89253.8942.830.00
2021-22242.32222.10221.3420.220.76
2022-23245.51238.52237.706.990.82
Total1,318.001228.261223.5489.744.72

CAG India, Report No. 5 of 2025, Table 8.3, printed p.96 / PDF p.130. Unit: lakh books, two decimals as reported. Differences are arithmetic on rounded source values, not causal stages or exact individual-book counts.

Source: CAG India, Odisha Report No. 5 of 2025, Table 8.3. Original secondary figure by Alisson Bento. Separate from sampled block inventories.

Download chart (SVG) ↓ · Download chart (PNG) ↓

Different local counts call for different checks

Nine sampled block book records within the 2018–23 audit window, including previous-year stock. Local quantity deficits and remaining school-supply gaps are descriptive arithmetic envelopes, not usable matching stock.

Full chart and source
Nine block bars split local quantity deficit from remaining school-supply gap. Nandahandi has only the first term; Bhandaripokhari and Boipariguda only the second; Bonth and Ullunda have both. Zero gaps do not certify every title supplied, including Semiliguda.

Scroll horizontally to inspect the chart. ↔

Chart and values

Scroll horizontally to see all columns.

Nine sampled block records: a quantity envelope
BlockRequiredAvailable including prior stockSupplied to schoolsA: local quantity deficitB: remaining school-supply gap
Bonth484,636481,692471,2472,94410,445
Bhandaripokhari370,718372,403359,768010,950
Boipariguda423,012423,012418,10004,912
Semiliguda369,281369,281369,28100
Kosagumuda868,773870,614868,77300
Nandahandi290,046255,809255,80934,2370
Nuapada580,195609,290580,19500
Birmaharajpur335,358335,358335,35800
Ullunda294,353272,844263,65621,5099,188
Total4,016,3723,990,3033,922,18758,69035,495

CAG India, Appendix 8.4, printed p.128 / PDF p.166; audit window 2018–23, including previous-year stock. Counts are books as reported. A = max(required − available, 0); B = min(required, available) − supplied. No matching usable stock or feasible transfer is identified. Source reports subject imbalances. Semiliguda separately had unmet requests covering 32,827 textbooks for 2018–22; a zero aggregate gap is not an all-clear.

Source: CAG India, Appendix 8.4. Original secondary figure by Alisson Bento. Subject imbalances and separate Semiliguda unmet requests prevent a zero-gap all-clear.

Download chart (SVG) ↓ · Download chart (PNG) ↓

Data & downloads

Scroll horizontally to see all columns.

Five statewide annual book-count balances
Academic yearRequiredPrintedSuppliedRequired − printedPrinted − supplied
2018-19272.20260.09258.5612.111.53
2019-20261.25253.66252.057.591.61
2020-21296.72253.89253.8942.830.00
2021-22242.32222.10221.3420.220.76
2022-23245.51238.52237.706.990.82
Total1,318.001228.261223.5489.744.72

CAG India, Report No. 5 of 2025, Table 8.3, printed p.96 / PDF p.130. Unit: lakh books, two decimals as reported. Differences are arithmetic on rounded source values, not causal stages or exact individual-book counts.

Scroll horizontally to see all columns.

Nine sampled block records: a quantity envelope
BlockRequiredAvailable including prior stockSupplied to schoolsA: local quantity deficitB: remaining school-supply gap
Bonth484,636481,692471,2472,94410,445
Bhandaripokhari370,718372,403359,768010,950
Boipariguda423,012423,012418,10004,912
Semiliguda369,281369,281369,28100
Kosagumuda868,773870,614868,77300
Nandahandi290,046255,809255,80934,2370
Nuapada580,195609,290580,19500
Birmaharajpur335,358335,358335,35800
Ullunda294,353272,844263,65621,5099,188
Total4,016,3723,990,3033,922,18758,69035,495

CAG India, Appendix 8.4, printed p.128 / PDF p.166; audit window 2018–23, including previous-year stock. Counts are books as reported. A = max(required − available, 0); B = min(required, available) − supplied. No matching usable stock or feasible transfer is identified. Source reports subject imbalances. Semiliguda separately had unmet requests covering 32,827 textbooks for 2018–22; a zero aggregate gap is not an all-clear.

Scroll horizontally to see all columns.

Due and last-supply dates at block points
Academic yearDue dateLast supply dateEndpoint delay, days
2018–1915 March 201813 June 201890
2019–2015 March 201923 July 2019130
2020–2115 March 202022 September 2020191
2021–2215 March 202129 September 2021198
2022–2315 March 202226 September 2022195

CAG India, Table 8.2, printed p.96 / PDF p.130. Endpoint calendar differences only: no quantity delivered by deadline, average delay or pupil waiting duration is observed.

Evidence & method

How we calculated it

  1. Secondary transcription of CAG India, Government of Odisha School Education Report No. 5 of 2025: Tables 8.2 and 8.3, printed page 96 (PDF page 130), and Appendix 8.4, printed page 128 (PDF page 166). Statewide annual quantities and sampled block stock records are analysed separately. The protocol preceded full report retrieval and calculation.
  2. Annual arithmetic uses the reported two-decimal lakh book values. Local quantity deficit is max(requirement − availability, 0); remaining school-supply gap is min(requirement, availability) − supply. Both are descriptive count differences, not identified causes or usable-stock estimates. Calendar differences use only Table 8.2 due and last-supply dates.

What the data cannot tell us

  • Historical audited years 2018–19 through 2022–23; audit fieldwork April–December 2023, report tabled 9 December 2025. Source files verified on 1 November 2026 UTC. No current 2026 textbook availability, learning effect, individual student experience or causal programme effect is measured.
  • The annual statewide cohorts, nine sampled block records including previous-year stock, 77-school elementary context and 46-school student-set table have different coverage. No population estimate, combined funnel, student ratio, title matching, feasible transfer or quantity-weighted waiting statistic is inferred.
  • Source subject-mix imbalances and the separate unmet Semiliguda requests covering 32,827 textbooks prevent a zero aggregate gap from certifying fulfilled needs. Annual lakh quantities retain source rounding; block quantities are integer counts as reported.

Original sources

  1. CAG India: Odisha School Education, Report No. 5 of 2025

    Original CAG audit: Table 8.2 endpoint dates; Table 8.3 annual lakh book quantities; Appendix 8.4 local counts including previous-year stock. Main text page 96 supplies subject-mix and Semiliguda scope warnings.

    Accessed October 31, 2026

  2. CAG India: official report version and tabling metadata

    Official report metadata distinguishes the date sent to government, 8 October 2025, from the date tabled, 9 December 2025.

    Accessed October 31, 2026

  3. CAG India: copyright policy

    CAG copyright policy permits free, accurate and nonmisleading reproduction with prominent source acknowledgment, excluding third-party material. This package uses aggregate facts and original analysis only.

    Accessed October 31, 2026

Cite & reuse this study

Alisson Bento. Which Textbook Supply Gap Can the Record Actually Locate? Odisha, 2018–23. Secondary structured reference based on CAG India, Government of Odisha School Education Report No. 5 of 2025, Tables 8.2–8.3 and Appendix 8.4. https://alissonbento.com/research/odisha-textbook-supply-counts-and-delivery-endpoints-2018-2023/

Original secondary analysis and figures by Alisson Bento. Aggregate factual transcription: CAG India, Report No. 5 of 2025; cite the original audit and retain historical scope, units and limitations. CAG permits accurate, nonmisleading reuse with prominent acknowledgment; third-party material is excluded. Full source report and images are not redistributed.

Corrections or editorial questions

Pass it on.

Which Textbook Supply Gap Can the Record Actually Locate? Odisha, 2018–23 | Alisson Bentoalissonbento.com

WhatsAppFacebookXTelegramRedditThreadsEmailSMS